Bridge Between Soul and Science: Ken Wilber

photo by Doncoombez via Unsplash

I’m a practical philosophical mystic. It’s a contradiction.

I care about work with boots, shovels, and teeth – I want to see it work. The philosopher wants logic and proof that holds true all the way down. And the mystic feels things that transcend it all and has zero interest in justification.

We ALL have those parts. And the idiotic conviction they somehow don’t talk to each other is shredding us and continually pulling us off course.

I want all these in the same room. That’s WHY I’m writing, if I’m honest. I’m trying to build a space to hold my own contradictions. And hopefully yours too.

Creative life is just the fruiting body of the mushroom – it’s the shiny red, spotted blip that comes out the top of something with very deep roots, that carries messages between trees, breaks down the old, and makes food for the new.

This is a philosophical foundation piece to hold the practical, philosophical, and mystical in the same room. To be whole. And to recover the right to talk about the mythology of our inner lives in a non-woo way.

It’s a bit different than usual – there’s a lot of Ken Wilber in here, it’s denser than I’d like. And I want this to work for easy reference so you can figure out what I’m talking about later.

So fair warning.

The Problem

From three angles, the problem is:

  1. Creative work too easily collapses into hustle culture productivity (word counts, hours spent, money made, likes). Those are all sensory/physical metrics that collapse the mental/emotional depth needed to MAKE THE WORK.

  2. Philosophy, personal development, and most spiritual systems (like astrology, tarot, metaphysics, runes) provide mental frameworks that don’t lead to useful experiences, either in the physical world or emotionally/spiritually.

  3. Stories and myths are how people have encoded emotional/spiritual info for thousands of years, but we don’t break these down far enough to see how they provide emotional “how to” experiences in our lives, so we don’t have a map for these experiences.

These are all symptoms of the same problem. We keep collapsing our different modes of knowing (sensory, mental, and emotional/spiritual) into each other before they can produce the needed result.

So the task is to figure out how to hold the three together in a healthy relationship so each can flourish without squishing the others. And then how to make progress within each mode.

The project here is to build a foundation that can hold all three.

We’re doing this with the work of Ken Wilber, via his book Marriage of Sense and Soul, where he tries to build a mutually acceptable foundation for both science and religion to interact.

We’re going to go in depth into what he thinks, why I think it works well, and where it doesn’t. But for mercy-sake, and so we can refer back to this easily later: BEHOLD THE NUTSHELL VERSION.

TL;DR – In a Nutshell

Science and religion can get along if they agree that:

  • There are three modes of knowing that give us different results (sensory, mind, and contemplation)

  • All valid knowledge needs to go through three basic stages (how to statement /injunction, direct experience, peer review)

  • Everything has an inner and outer dimension, just like every box has a height, width, and length.

Science doesn’t get to say everything has to be sensory; religion doesn’t get to be dogmatic or require literal beliefs in myths. But they can agree on testable experiences in their lanes.

HOWEVER – I think tossing out all myths is getting rid of the baby with the bathwater. There are thousands of years of human emotional/spiritual experiences encoded in mythology and folklore, injunctions we couldn’t say in any other way. So navigating our human experience requires translating these myths down far enough that we can find the experiential injunctions (how to live to get X) in them.

Subscribe now

Modernity Doesn’t Suck That Bad. It’s Science Taking Over That’s A Problem.

Before Modernity took over, suppose you were a mammoth hunter. Your tribe believes that to find more mammoth to hunt, you had to honor the souls of the mammoth. It’s morally right to participate in the community mammoth-soul-ritual.

But you have a problem. Bob doesn’t believe in the souls of mammoths – so unfortunately you are going to have to kill Bob. His crazy lack of belief means the mammoth herds won’t come and everyone will starve – it’s immoral.

External physical reality, personal internal experiences, and internal group morality are all in one pile.

Now, fast forward to Galileo.

He looks through a telescope and sees things in the sky that the church says shouldn’t be there.

But now Modernity is here – so we DON’T HAVE TO KILL GALILEO! He can go sit in his house, the church will look the other way, and they can just politely pretend not to see each other.

Modernity separates the spheres. It says science (regarding objective “IT” reality), morality (regarding group internal “WE” reality), and art (regarding internal personal “I” reality) can each grow separately, without having to affect the others (more on this division of reality later).

This leads to a lot of good things – like equality, human rights, democracy, liberty, personal freedom, and modern medicine.

But once separate, science quickly outgrew the other two dimensions of human experience.

And because some physical things have been found to describe internal experience (your brain and neurotransmitters can indicate depression) this was taken to mean that ALL internal experiences are only as real as their physical passports. All the internal, left hand experiences were collapsed to the right side, into physical experiences.

And we’ve been trying to recover our inner lives ever since.

Dominant Physical Reality

This is why hustle culture and productivity and making money have so much gravitational pull. They are part of physical reality – they get to be real.

When we are struggling with uncertainty and need validation, we gravitate towards what our culture validates the most – science, objective reality, physical things that you can see moving around.

That’s not to say that you should go starve in a shanty being “spiritual”. The point is that ALL THREE modes need to be in balance. Taking care of physical reality is important, but so is taking care of your mental/emotional and spiritual self.

Recovering the Inner Life, Three Failed Escapes

Humans, generally, have not been very happy with the idea of being flat, empty bags of molecules traipsing around.

Wilber discusses three general ways different schools of thought have tried to justify a return to inner life under the eye of science. All of them have failed in his opinion though, either to make something that preserves the gains of modernity, or that is generally true or reachable.

1) Romantics Return to the Past

These are schools of thought that return to the “noble savage” of the 1800s. This might look like a vision of radical ecology or “trad wives” that involves a kind of aspirational nostalgia for a “time when things were better.” When the inner life was alive – and one with everything else in your life.

Except things weren’t that good back then. We still had to kill Bob for not believing in mammoth souls. All those nice advances that help us replace broken kidneys and support human rights and liberty weren’t around – it’s really just a return to the dark ages in nice clothes. We lose all the advantages of modernity.

2) Idealists Don’t Have a Practice

Idealists give you a beautiful dream for the future, but there’s no way to get there reliably. Wilber talks about Hegel and the idea of a world soul, a self-aware universe in all things that unites objective and subjective awareness, that grows first through sleeping to itself, then dual awareness, and then through transcendent non-duality. But there’s no way for regular people to reach non-dual awareness.

I see this in modern manifestation culture or positive thinking spirituality. The idea is nice – if you focus on the right things, only good things will come into your life. In practice though, there’s no reliable way to get there.

3) Postmodernism Destroys Shared Truth

Postmodernism just flattens all forms of shared truth, saying that all truth is just subjective. It refers to nothing real, so anyone’s “truth” is as good as anyone else’s. Except, as Wilber notes, we are all pointing to something when we talk about a turtle, for example, so there is some kind of objective reality out there.

An example of this would be Cancel Culture, and the idea that, if I don’t like it, we can just get rid of it – it has no validity beyond how I feel about it.

Wilber’s Resolution: 3 Modes, 3 Scientific Steps, Sacrifices

Wilber resolves this problem in a few big sweeps.

  • There are three modes of understanding (sensory, mental, and contemplative); religion and science have to stay in their lane to stay valid.

  • The scientific method breaks down to injunctions (how-to’s), direct experience, and peer review. You can do it for science AND religion.

  • Everything has an external (right side objective) dimension and an internal (left side subjective) dimension.

  • Both sides have to give something up. Science can’t pretend to be narrowly about sensory data with no thinking, and religion has to give up dogma and mythology.

  • Taken together, we have terms of agreement.

The Three “Eyes” of Knowing

There are probably multiple “eyes of knowing”, but for simplicity’s sake we’re just going to go with three.

  • The “eye of the senses” is sensory knowledge.

  • The “eye of mind” is rational knowledge, like math, logic, or mental constructs that help you think about things.

  • The “eye of contemplation” is for spiritual or mystical experiences.

Each form of knowing is distinct and gives knowledge of its own kind – data that works best in its own lane.

You can rationally understand, say, why your hand feels hot when you hold a hot cup of tea (sensory). But you can’t necessarily use your senses to understand calculus (rational) or meditation (contemplative).

Sensory data, in other words, isn’t going to tell us much about rational or contemplative levels of awareness. We can do an MRI on someone meditating and derive sensory data about their brain waves, but that doesn’t contain the WHOLE experience. We have to perceive it through contemplative awareness to get a full meditative experience.

You also often have to have the right training for the experience to make sense to you. If you don’t know calculus, the “experience of thinking through a calculus equation” is not going to do a lot for you. But if you’ve spent 5 years studying calculus, it might mean a lot.

The Essentials of An Agile “Scientific” Method

The point of the scientific method is to make experiences verifiable. We have to be able to tell if something is true or not, right?

Wilber breaks it down into three steps (my examples):

  1. Injunction, a “do this to get that” statement. “Look through a microscope to see a wiggly cell.” Or, “Sit in zazen meditation 6 hours a day for 6 years to attain higher awareness.”

  2. Direct experience. In any case, you have to experience the thing. You see the cell. You feel enlightenment.

  3. Peer review. After you do the thing, you take it back to a community of peers who have also done it, to compare notes. “Did you also see a wiggly cell? Yes!” or perhaps, “Did you also want to ride a llama backwards after enlightenment? NO!? Maybe I need to sit for longer…”

Because we have a how-to, a direct experience (perceived through the appropriate “eye”), and a peer review process, we have a way of fact checking our experiences, whether they are physical, mental or spiritual, EVEN if they cannot be seen through a microscope. We’ve got validity back for internal experiences, in other words.

Everything Has an Internal and External Dimension

Wilber envisions it as a square divided into a 2 x 2 grid. On the Right Side is objective reality, external. And on the Left Side is subjective reality, the internal.

Like the dimensions of your floor or a table, which always have a length, width, and height, likewise everything appears in both internal and external reality.

Sacrifices for Science and Religion to Agree

Like any marriage, they each have to give up a few things to get along.

Science doesn’t get to pretend that ONLY sensory reality is real (Wilber points out that science believes in math and logic and uses it all the time anyway, which is rational, not sensory. So science already kind of agrees that other modes of knowing are real).

Religion, on the other hand, has to give up dogma and the strict belief that mythology is literally true. Since taking it literally is the point of myth to true believers of religion, according to Wilber, and we can’t literally justify something like a virgin birth to science, we have to throw out the myth.

“…the concrete-literal forms of mythology cannot withstand – and have not withstood – the tests of modernity: those concrete claims are indeed bogus. And if religion is to survive in a viable form in the modern world, it must be willing to jettison its bogus claims, just as narrow science must be willing to jettison its reductionistic imperialism.” (Wilber, Ch. 12)

Symbolic readings of myth also fail, according to Wilber, because true believers don’t accept them (although thoroughly addressing this is a job for another essay).

Nonetheless, the founders of most religions based their teachings on some kind of direct experience – sitting under a tree for three days or in a cave. We can focus on their direct experiences as a foundation.

And there we have it – science and religion can agree by staying in their experiential lanes. Science can do sensory and mental experiments. Religion can do contemplative experiments, and they can agree they are both real.

Implications

Personally, I like this setup. I like that we have three modes of knowing, and even the idea that a different mode of understanding might be needed when we are confused by something, or not getting the result we expect.

First, it explains why “creative work” keeps sliding into “productivity”. Because only physical reality seems real. But we NEED the inner life too.

Second, it explains the domain and limits of philosophy and many spiritual teachings.

One of my big challenges has been wanting to build a foundation to discuss spiritual stuff, like runes, tarot, astrology, and near-death-experiences, without having to chloroform philosophy and tie him up in the back room.

This explains perfectly why the two sides don’t get along. Philosophy is rational, and comes up with rational, mental info to help us DECIDE, mentally, how to live. But it doesn’t directly translate into physical action or spiritual experience.

Likewise, a lot of spiritual teachings are mental constructs. Which is why astrology doesn’t really change how you live. In my experience, unless it is translated into practices, it just gives you ideas for how to think differently.

However, on my third problem – how to deal with myth – Wilber and I disagree.

Don’t Throw Out the Baby With the Bath Water

I totally agree with Wilber that dogmatic, literal understandings of mythology doesn’t really help us much right now. Unless we are talking picking historical events out of a story (which a lot of myths do).

But, saying we have to get rid of all mythology because some are intended to be taken literally, is like saying we have to get rid of all crowbars because some are used to rob cars. Yes, certainly, some are used inappropriately. But that doesn’t mean we have to get rid of all of them.

Myth, folklore, and stories are how humanity has encoded all kinds of emotional, spiritual experiences for thousands of years.

Like dream interpretation, myth, folklore, and stories have been so important to our collective consciousness because they point to deeper material that we haven’t had words for. They are rich with ideas about how your feelings fit in a larger process, and how you can move through your situation to resolution.

In other words, translated into feelings and states we can recognize, myth and stories contain emotional and spiritual INJUNCTIONS for how to move through experiences.

The work, then, is to translate myth into something we can see ourselves in and use to guide our steps.

Translating Myth for Emotional Cellars

It’s like walking down the stairs in the dark. If you don’t know where to feel for the railing or the next step, you are going to fall. But if you have a basic understanding of stairsteps, you know what to feel for.

So this is the project – to describe ways to deal with the dark cellar of our emotional, spiritual experiences, our depths, by translating our myths enough to see the injunctions, live through the experiences, and compare notes.

This is partly why our culture is starving for depth.

We’ve cut ourselves off from thousands of years of root-growth in an effort to be practical. And now it’s time to head back down into the dark, and see what treasures we can recover.

Thanks for reading,

Morgan

For more (generally less long and complicated) essays on feeding the roots of creative life, sub here.

P.S. Enjoy Ken Wilber? There’s more on him and his grid here:


Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *